Florida's Stand Your Ground Law: Deadly Force vs. Non-Deadly Force

Florida’s Stand Your Ground law is one of the most debated and misunderstood legal doctrines in the country. If you live in Palm Beach County or anywhere in Florida, chances are you’ve heard about it in the news, usually in connection with high-profile criminal cases. But what does the law actually mean? When can you legally defend yourself, and how is “Stand Your Ground” different from traditional self-defense?

This blog will break down the basics of Florida’s Stand Your Ground law, clarify the difference between deadly force and non-deadly force, and explain how this law differs from the broader concept of self-defense. If you’ve been arrested in Palm Beach County and believe you acted in self-defense, understanding this law could be critical to your case.

Schedule a Consultation

What is Florida’s Stand Your Ground Law?

Florida Statutes §776.012 and related provisions form the backbone of the state’s Stand Your Ground law. Enacted in 2005, the law removed the traditional “duty to retreat” before using force in self-defense. In simple terms, this means:

• If you are in a place where you have a legal right to be,

• You are not engaged in unlawful activity, and

• You reasonably believe force is necessary to prevent death, great bodily harm, or the commission of a forcible felony,

Then you may use force, including deadly force, without first trying to retreat.

This is a major departure from older self-defense laws, which often required a person to attempt escape before resorting to force, unless they were inside their own home (the “Castle Doctrine”). Florida’s law expands those protections to almost anywhere you have the right to be.

The Difference Between Deadly Force and Non-Deadly Force

One of the most important distinctions under Florida law is the type of force used, non-deadly versus deadly.

Non-Deadly Force

Under §776.012(1), Fla. Stat., a person is justified in using or threatening to use non-deadly force if they reasonably believe it is necessary to defend themselves or another against the imminent use of unlawful force.

Examples of non-deadly force include:

• Pushing someone away who grabs you.

• Restraining someone to stop them from hitting you.

• Shoving someone to escape a confrontation.

The key is that the force used is not likely to cause death or great bodily harm.

Deadly Force

Deadly force is a much higher threshold. Under §776.012(2), Fla. Stat., a person is justified in using or threatening to use deadly force if they reasonably believe it is necessary to:

• Prevent imminent death or great bodily harm to themselves or another, or

• Prevent the imminent commission of a forcible felony (such as robbery, burglary, or sexual battery).

Deadly force includes:

• Firing a gun at someone.

• Using a knife or blunt object in a way that could kill.

• Striking someone in a manner likely to cause serious injury.

The distinction matters. The law holds that you can only escalate to deadly force if the threat itself is deadly or involves a forcible felony. Using deadly force in response to a minor threat, like a shove or verbal insult, will not be justified under Florida law.

Stand Your Ground vs. Traditional Self-Defense

While Stand Your Ground is a type of self-defense, it’s not the same thing. Understanding the difference is critical if you’re facing criminal charges.

Self-Defense (Without Stand Your Ground)

Self-defense is a long-standing legal doctrine that allows you to protect yourself when threatened. Traditionally, however, self-defense came with a duty to retreat: you had to try to escape the situation if possible before resorting to force. Only if retreat was impossible, or if you were in your home under the Castle Doctrine, could you legally stand your ground.

Stand Your Ground (Florida’s Version)

Florida’s Stand Your Ground law goes further:

• No Duty to Retreat: If you are in a place where you have the right to be, you do not have to try to run away before defending yourself.

• Pretrial Immunity Hearing: Florida law provides that a person claiming Stand Your Ground can request a pretrial hearing. If successful, the case may be dismissed before ever going to trial.

• Broader Application: The law extends beyond the home, covering public spaces, vehicles, and anywhere else you’re legally allowed to be.

How Jury Instructions on Self-Defense Differ From Stand Your Ground

When someone raises a claim of self-defense in a Florida criminal trial, the jury is given detailed instructions on how to evaluate that claim. For example, the standard instruction on the justifiable use of non-deadly force tells jurors that a defendant is justified in using such force only if:

1. The defendant reasonably believed the force was necessary to defend against another person’s imminent use of unlawful force; and

2. The threat of unlawful force appeared to be immediate.

Jurors are also told that the defendant must be judged by the circumstances as they reasonably appeared at the time, and that the danger doesn’t need to be “actual”—only that a reasonably cautious person would have believed it to be real.

But here’s where self-defense and Stand Your Ground diverge:

• Self-Defense (Traditional Instruction): Jurors decide after the fact whether the defendant was justified. There is no automatic immunity; the case proceeds to trial unless the prosecution drops it.

• Stand Your Ground: A defendant can request a pretrial immunity hearing. If successful, the charges can be dismissed before the case ever reaches a jury. Stand Your Ground essentially provides a shield from prosecution, not just a defense at trial.

In other words, self-defense is a reactive argument presented during trial, while Stand Your Ground can be a proactive motion to avoid trial altogether.

Key Legal Considerations in a Florida Stand Your Ground Case

If you or someone you know has been arrested and is considering a Stand Your Ground defense, it’s important to understand the legal hurdles involved.

1. Reasonableness of Belief

   • The court will assess whether a reasonable person in your position would have believed deadly or non-deadly force was necessary.

2. Imminence of Threat

   • The threat must be immediate—not a vague future fear.

3. Unlawful Activity

   • If you were committing a crime at the time of the incident, you may not be entitled to Stand Your Ground protections.

4. Forcible Felonies

   • The law specifically identifies certain crimes (e.g., robbery, kidnapping, sexual assault) where deadly force is presumed reasonable to stop the act.

5. Burden of Proof

   • In 2017, Florida law shifted the burden of proof at immunity hearings from the defendant to the prosecution once a prima facia case is set forth in a motion. Now, prosecutors must prove by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant was not justified in using force.

Common Misconceptions About Stand Your Ground

• “You can shoot anyone who threatens you.”
  False. The law requires an imminent threat of death, great bodily harm, or a forcible felony.

• “It’s a free pass to use violence.”
  False. Stand Your Ground is not a blanket immunity; courts scrutinize these claims carefully.

• “It only applies in your home.”
  False. That’s the Castle Doctrine. Stand Your Ground applies anywhere you have a legal right to be.

Real-World Implications in Palm Beach County

Stand Your Ground defenses have been raised in high-profile Florida cases, and local judges in Palm Beach County handle these motions regularly. Whether the defense is successful depends on the facts: who initiated the confrontation, the level of threat, and whether the response was proportionate.

For example:

• A person attacked in a parking lot may be justified in drawing a firearm if the attacker threatens them with a knife.

• A homeowner may be justified in shooting an armed burglar entering their home.

• But a bar fight that escalates because someone threw a drink may not justify pulling a gun.

Every case is fact-specific, and small details often make the difference between immunity and a prison sentence.

Why a Proven Criminal Defense Attorney is Critical to Your Case

Florida’s Stand Your Ground law offers powerful protections, but it is not a simple defense to raise. The difference between deadly force and non-deadly force, and between self-defense and Stand Your Ground, can mean the difference between walking free and facing years in prison.

If you’ve been arrested in Palm Beach County and believe you acted in self-defense, you need an experienced criminal defense attorney who understands how to properly present a Stand Your Ground motion and argue your case in court.

At The Law Office of Matthew Konecky, P.A., our criminal defense attorney have years of experience defending clients in cases involving self-defense, Stand Your Ground, and serious criminal charges. We know what’s at stake—your freedom, your career, and your reputation—and we’re ready to fight for you.

Schedule a Consultation

Contact Our Palm Beach Criminal Lawyer for Your Case Challenging Florida's Stand Your Ground Law

You deserve a defense that is proactive, strategic, and immediate. Whether you're in Palm Beach County, Broward, Miami-Dade, Martin, or St. Lucie County, our firm is ready to step in and protect your freedom.

Contact us online or give our office a call (561) 671-5995 to schedule a confidential consultation now.